UK Inside vs Outside IR35 & Umbrella Pay Calculator
Negotiating a UK contract? Model a take-home-pay difference between an umbrella PAYE scenario and a PSC scenario. IR35 status and the correct payroll treatment depend on the contract and actual working practices.
TaxNomadix scenario report — Inside vs outside IR35
£500/day, 44 weeks · outside IR35 advantage £3,208 a year
Generated · taxnomadix.io · Educational estimate, not tax advice.
UK Inside vs Outside IR35 & Umbrella Pay Calculator
HMRC Off-Payroll Working rules: Compare deemed PAYE employment taxes against Ltd Company dividend payouts.
Advanced PAYE and umbrella reconciliation
Annual Contract Turnover: £110,000
Inside IR35 (Umbrella PAYE)
59.6% retainedOutside IR35 (Ltd Company)
62.5% retainedContractor note: Status depends on actual working practices. The 2026/27 model now supports pension salary sacrifice, Plans 1/2/4/5, postgraduate loans and accrued holiday pay. Accrued holiday is deferred cash rather than tax and should be set to 0 when rolled up. Benefits, tax codes, Scottish rates, employment costs and umbrella-specific reconciliation can still differ.
How IR35 Directly Affects Your Contractor Retention
The Inside IR35 Tax Hit
This illustration models 2026/27 employer NI at 15% above the secondary threshold, employee NI at 8%/2%, PAYE and a 0.5% levy assumption. Actual umbrella reconciliation, holiday pay, pension, expenses and employer levy treatment vary.
The Outside IR35 Dividend Route
A genuinely outside-IR35 engagement may be operated through a company, subject to status, company-tax, payroll, dividend and expense rules. The modeled salary/dividend mix is illustrative and is not automatically optimal or available.
Primary sources
Links checked Sep 24, 2026
- HMRCUnderstanding off-payroll working (IR35)Who decides IR35 status and who pays the tax
- HMRCCheck employment status for tax (CEST)
- HMRCWorking through an umbrella company
- HMRCRates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027Employee and employer Class 1 NIC used in umbrella modelling
- GOV.UKIncome Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- GOV.UKCorporation Tax rates and reliefs
- GOV.UKTax on dividends
Rules change. Where our summary and the authority differ, the authority wins. See how every figure is sourced on the sources & methodology page.
